Saturday, March 14, 2009

Life insurance quotation gives misleading information

A policyholder bought a 21 year anticipated endowment policy with an annual payment of $14,500. The quotation clearly stated that a sumof $20,000 is paid every 3 years and the payment on maturity is $80,000 plus RB/SB of $264,800 giving a total payout of $344,800.  There was no explanation about the RB/SB and that it is not guaranteed. The policyholder was misled by the agent into believing that the payment is guaranteed.

The policy is now approaching the maturity date. The policyholder is now told that the actual maturity payout is only $232,400, comprising of $80,000 plus RB/SB of 152,400 (i.e. decrease of $102,400) from the quotation. The policyholder was shocked to see this amount of reduction.

I advised the policyholder to file a complaint to FIDREC and, if not resolved, to take a legal case.

MY VIEW: 
Now I know why this insurance company was so successful in its sales over the past years. The agents were able to sell large policies by providing misleading quotations to the customers. Most of these customers are not well educated and trusted the verbal explanation of the agents. When they learned the truth years later, it was too late. 

The root cause of this problem is the excessive commission paid to the agent and the poor supervision of the insurance company on the conduct of their agents. I hope that this unhealthy practice is properly addressed.

Low cash value on termination

Dear Sir,
I have a PRUCASH policy that started in 2002. The annual premium is $3934. The coverage is very low at $50,000 because it is meant to be an endowment plan. The annual cashback is $2500.

I've only recently educated myself through your website and other sources on how insurance and savings should really work and realised how big a mistake I made when I bought that policy.
The cash value now is about $16000, whereas my premiums paid to date is about $27000.
If I surrender my policy now, I'll "lose" around $9000.


What is my best course of action?Should I continue with the policy and take out the cashback yearly to invest in a low-cost ETF? Or should I terminate the policy and invest in an ETF with the entire sum? The difference in yields required for me to make up that $9000 loss seems to be quite huge.

REPLY
You should ask the insurance company to explain why you had to lose so much money, if you terminate it now. They owe an explanation to you.

To make a decision on whether to continue or terminate the policy, you should ask for additional information. Please read the relevant document in my website, www.tankinlian.com/faq